The forest in Pines feels alive in the worst possible way. Not magical. Not whimsical. Watching.
Blake Crouch builds tension through constant disorientation. Ethan Burke wakes up injured, isolated, and increasingly unsure whether the people around him are trying to help him, manipulate him, or quietly prepare him for something horrifying. Every answer creates three new questions. Every interaction feels just slightly off-center.
What surprised me most about Pines was how readable it was. Despite the horror elements, the pacing is so sharp and cinematic that the pages practically turn themselves. This is the kind of book that makes you say “just one more chapter” right before accidentally reading half the novel in one sitting.
Hype Report
Goodreads: 3.9 | Storygraph: 3.81
My Take: Appropriately-Hyped
Aesthetic
The Cover
The cover imagery of Pines is so disconcerting. You are both looking up into the trees and down from above. Coupled with the fog, it is quite eerie. The lines that divide the image call to mind several associations at the same time – kaleidoscope fractals, divisions, a clock, and a targeting system. Combined with the circled one in the very center it feels like a countdown to something ominous.
The colors are natural, but slightly unnerving with the sense that the forest is dying from the outside in.
The typographic choice feels very in tune with the pine tree imagery – straight and tall.
Interior
No complaints about the Pines ebook formatting.
Did the design affect whether I bought the book?
No. I really only bought Pines because of the association with my home state – Idaho. I chose to read this above the other options because it sounded the most interesting at the time of reading. The cover was not a factor.
Summary
In Short
A Secret Service agent arrives in a town to investigate the disappearance of two agents, but finds himself in a mysterious and dangerous situation where he is unable to contact the outside world and is surrounded by electrified fences.
From the Publisher
The first book of the smash-hit Wayward Pines trilogy, from the New York Times bestselling author of Dark Matter, Recursion, and Upgrade
One way in. No way out.
Secret Service agent Ethan Burke arrives in Wayward Pines, Idaho, with a mission: locate two federal agents who went missing in the bucolic town one month earlier. But within minutes of his arrival, Ethan is involved in a violent accident. He comes to in a hospital, with no ID, no cell phone, and no briefcase.
As the days pass, Ethan’s investigation turns up more questions than answers: Why can’t he get any phone calls through to his wife and son in the outside world? Why doesn’t anyone believe he is who he says he is? And what is the purpose of the electrified fences surrounding the town? Are they meant to keep the residents in? Or something else out?
Each step closer to the truth takes Ethan farther from the world he knew, from the man he was, until he must face a horrifying fact—he may never get out of Wayward Pines alive.
The nail-bitingly suspenseful opening installment in Blake Crouch’s blockbuster Wayward Pines trilogy, Pines is at once a brilliant mystery tale and the first step into a genre-bending saga of suspense, science fiction, and horror.
Character Analysis
Ethan Burke has serious action hero energy. Seriously, this guy is constantly beaten to a pulp and keeps forging ahead undeterred. He’s got some complicated emotional baggage and a somewhat strained relationship with his wife, whom he hasn’t been a stellar husband to. He loves his son, but barely knows the kid. Burke is clearly intelligent and determined, and in peak physical condition.
We also see a few scenes from Theresa Burke’s point of view. This defines her in the narrowest terms and does more to reinforce who Ethan is and the relationship that they share. Ethan is really the only character with dimension.
Pines is a plot-driven story, and while there is a notable main character, the story is not really about his development or personal journey. It’s about the interaction of this one person with a new, challenging, mysterious environment.
Writing Style
Crouch’s writing is very cinematic. It is easy to see why the Wayward Pines trilogy and other works by Crouch have been adapted for TV and film. This extends to basically framing shots from the character’s actual POV.
He stared up at her–a strange angle fromhis supine position on the gurney that showed the underside of her chin, ler lips, her nose, the ceiling panels, and long fluorescent lightbulbs scrolling past.
The pace is fast. There is always something happening. Lots of dramatic suspense, jump scares, and some gore. If you haven’t seen Wayward Pines, the 2015-16 TV show, or the inspiration for the series Twin Peaks, you might think of this as the mystery of Lost meets the suspense of Bourne Identity meets the designed gore of Kill Bill. At least that was what was going through my head when I read it. Human evolution and nature’s response is sharply juxtaposed against idyllic Norman Rockwell variety Americana.
His experience, there was darkness everywhere human beings gathered. The way of the world. Perfection was a surface thing. The epidermis. Cut a few layers deep, you begin to see some darker shades. Cut to the bone–pitch black.
Themes
Control underpins the majority of the Pines story. Continuously placing Burke in situations where he has none and seeks to gain some, is nearly rhythmic in its repetition and variation across the story of Pines. This is heightened by flashback scenes, surveillance, sedation, being trapped in various ways, and within the constructs of the man-vs-nature theme.
Man against nature becomes more evident in the second half of the book, but it is invariably a key theme. Could this be considered Cli-Fi (climate fiction)? Possibly. Isolation and survival, both of an individual and a species, are baked into the setting, the background, the plot, and the character.
Identity and perception are challenged from beginning to end as the mystery of Pines is gradually revealed and Burke wavers between knowing exactly who he is and questioning everything.
Since the Industrial Revolution, we’ve treated our world like it was a hotel room and we were rock stars.
Critical Evaluation
The themes in Pines are well-established and clearly implemented. The constant sense of unease is baked into the tone and plot structure.
I want to comment on the treatment of the husband-wife relationship. While there is some resolution at the end of the book, Ethan doesn’t have any real emotional response. His thoughts about his wife seem to be more obligatory that admiration based. There is a sense at the end of Pines that while Ethan is not technically alone, he is still isolated. I’m not entirely sure whether this is an intentional thematic element or a misstep.
There were moments when you saw the people you loved for who they really were, seperate from the baggage of projection and shared histories. When you saw them with fresh eyes, as a stranger might, and caught the feeling of the first time you loved them. Before the tears and the armor chinks. When there was still the possibility of perfection.
Cover Accuracy Rating?
Did the book cover accurately portray the book’s contents?
The cover of Pines is very indicative of the eerie, isolated, strange setting of Pines.
The people in town, for the most part, can’t handle the truth od what’s out there. But you…you can’t handle the lie.
Personal Opinion
I don’t normally read horror. In fact, I kind of avoid it. However, I had seen the Wayward Pines show more than ten years ago when it aired, and decided based on that that I could handle this. I am glad that I read Pines. It was very different from what I normally choose, but I was totally engaged throughout the whole book. This was great suspense with interesting themes. The creepy setting was so well done, not too over the top, and with plausible explanations.
Recommendation
Suspense/Horror freaks (←endearingly) will definitely find something to love in Pines.
Pines is not for you if you refuse to read anything that would fail the Bechdel test or if graphic violence is a hard stop.
Skip Pines if your reading taste leans toward character-driven stories with interpersonal relationships.
Native Idahoans will be equal parts creeped out and ‘eh, that sounds about right.’
Read Pines on a foggy, dreary day for maximum eerieness. Alternatively, give it a read in the first week of July if you feel like leaning into the throwback Americana, maybe pick up a retro rotary phone for your reading nook.
Notes
I read Pines to fulfill the Playing Card Reading Challenge prompt: Read a book set in your hometown/region. I’m from Idaho. It could also answer the prompt: Read a book with a one-word title.
You wake up in an unfamiliar place with no memories. Do you default to paranoia or acceptance?
Buy This Book
May your life be as full as your bookshelf and as long as your TBR list.
Happy Reading!
A Cheeky Journal For Your Imaginings
“Hallucinations” lined, 120-page, paperback journal.
0 Comments